Home
 
 
18 July 2007 @ 01:14 am
sometimes i repeat myself  
i just want to say i'm sorry if i keep saying the same things over and over in all these posts. i feel like i do. i think its just reflective of how i'm thinking, like all these things require thinking again and again and again. i'm amazed at how similar the things i wrote about this issue in 1999 are to what i'm writing now. what does that mean? that i'm not creating enough conversations to move to new places? i hope this is beginning to change with this rad conversation we're having here. i feel like all of this is stirred up in me in a more focused way than it has ever been before.

i was just talking to my friends emily and james about this conversation. one of the things we talked about was how we all feel different kinds of pressure from what our upbringings taught us about money and security and insecurity. it made me think about how much pressure we all feel from what our upbringings taught us about gender and sexuality, yet what a rich and robust set of communities i'm a part of that provide tons of space and models for resistant gender and sexual practices. i really don't think i could ever have openly identified as trans, and especially allowed myself to be a non-traditionally gendered queer trans person, without knowing that others existed and eventually meeting them and then more and more. still, when i hang out with certain friends like james who have really non-traditional trans identities i feel like his very existence opens space for me to be less judgmental toward myself and less internalizing of other people's transphobia toward me. i want to think about how we can do this with economic justice practice.

emily and i were talking about what a gathering of friends to discuss these themes might include. we talked about something like a dinner party, where people know they are specially invited and come with a more intimate and open feeling than a large event. we talked about how 70's feminist consciousness raising groups focused on people sharing openly and learning about sexism and feminism from each other's experiences. i like the idea of building shared analysis from what people already in the room know, and teaching each other. we also talked about creating a moment when people can all share their anxieties about the conversation at the beginning, in order to help people move out of a judgmental space and into a compassionate space, recognizing that we're all there together to help each other be the good people we are and build strategies to live that.

those ideas seem really smart for working with the group of friends emily and i share, who are familiar with and invested in feminist practice. i imagine other things would work better in other circles. we also thought that it would be essential at such an event to do a visioning exercise about what people think economic justice looks like, so that it wasn't just a depressing apathy-producing conversation, but was one about vision and practice. i can imagine planning something with emily with a certain group of friends we share, and i enjoyed how concrete it was to talk to her about it. i could imagine a dinner party/facilitated conversation like that resulting in that group of people doing a project of some kind together, making a zine, or deciding to meet again and that was fun to think about.

i keep having lots of these conversations with people in person who have or have not been reading this series of posts and comments. it seems like a main sticking point keeps being my bits about cell phones. in some ways, it makes me want to stop mentioning it, because it seems like such a stumbling block for some people that gets in the way of the rest of the conversation. in other ways, i feel like it kind of gets to the heart of what is hard here. why do we find each other's practices threatening? why do we need each other to do the same things or dismiss what others are doing?

i was thinking about environmental practices again, and how my friend asher moved to LA and got a veggie diesel car. its a great thing to do, and i am really excited to learn about it. yet, i don't feel threatened or defensive that its not something i can do right now. similarly, when i had a garden and composted all the time, i loved telling people about it and showing them, and none of them seemed to see it as an indictment of how they threw away vegetable scraps. why were we able to, in those conversations, each see other people making different contributions, recognize them as significant even though they are relatively small, find them inspiring, and still be engaged in different practices related to those principles in a non-defensive way? i want to think about flipping the money script to look more like that. so that nepon's story about selling the house in a way that reflected economic justice goals is fuel for our thinking, or someone else telling us they make their own sex toys instead of buying them, or someone else saying they've stopped buying coffee, or me saying i don't have a cell phone, are actions that we can reflect on and consider as options for ourselves and hear more about and embrace. i'm not quite sure what makes the argument about cell phones so hard to hear, and result in such vigorous defense of a product that, while it is not the root of all evil, can't really be argued to be a politically liberating or environmentally friendly or economically redistributionist item. i mean, does it deserve defense? i think i need to think about how i'm talking about it that might contribute to this. i want to approach these conversations non-judgmentally but still be allowed to have strong feelings about the products and marketing schemes and trends, while being clear that i'm not judging the buyers, though i am sharing my critique because i think it's worth something.

anyway, these thoughts are a bit disconnected. tyrone and i are working on ideas for creating some kind of space for this conversation and i'm so excited. we'll write with updates and requests for articles and stuff as it comes together.
 
 
( Post a new comment )
heath mackenzie[info]magnolienbaum on July 18th, 2007 01:28 pm (UTC)
why were we able to, in those conversations, each see other people making different contributions, recognize them as significant even though they are relatively small, find them inspiring, and still be engaged in different practices related to those principles in a non-defensive way? i want to think about flipping the money script to look more like that.

this, i think, is the thing that's tripping me up in these conversations. i inevitably feel judged because i don't really have the space, financially, to be very picky about my spending. and what little extra money i do have, i want to buy nice things, to wear to work, to wear on the town. it has always been and still is true that my extra cash goes towards class passing. i've been poor, actually and visibly, and i feel shame and embarrassment and a great, great fear about being there again, except this time it will be my fault, personally (because i haven't shaken that work ethic, the one that motivated me to go to college and grad school, that says if you play by the rules you'll never feel this way again. now i'm working class with more debt than anyone in my family has ever had, making more money than most of my family, but having just as much or less disposable income. i'm just as bound, just as stuck. but i took this all on myself, and it's hard to remember the mechanics of class that work hard to make sure poor and working class people stay that way).

i want to be able to have these conversations without feeling defensive, but its hard for me to pull apart - this is how i spend the money i use to survive, this is how i use my extra money. it's hard for me to not be jealous of friends who have money, or access to it, who are trying to use it responsibly, because deep in my heart i know that i want to have that leisure, to have a big chunk of money or other assets sitting under me so that when shit happens - like this bike accident i just got in - my first thought isn't "i can't afford to not be at work, what the fuck am i going to do?" but is instead about healing and taking the time i need. building community and community resources is totally important to this, absolutely. and i wonder if asking for those will always feel like hustling to get things i need (food, jackets, a place to stay that has adults around) from my friends and their parents felt while i was growing up.

maybe its in part about healing from growing up poor. and about building trust with folks with money. but i enter these conversations with such profound dis-ease and distrust, both because of where i've come from and because where i am now is still so financially tenuous. money scares me, and i don't know how to not be defensive about it. i feel like its treated as an intellectual exercise - how will i use this thing? - where my basic experience of money is about survival, until recently, where i've been working hard at building a life that is about desire instead of survival alone.
heath mackenzie[info]magnolienbaum on July 18th, 2007 01:36 pm (UTC)
oh, and also, i'm really glad you and tyrone are staring these conversations, dean. i very much want to be part of them, despite being thoroughly scared of them. maybe i cling to the scarcity of being poor and not having options because it's what i know best. this is what the choosing desire over survival is all about - learning to identify my options and choose the ones i really, truly, want. but that is scary, too - learning to see what really i and what really isnt an option. learning to see/say what i want, and then try to figure out how to get it. i never let myself admit that i wanted top surgery until recently because it wasn't - and still isn't - economically viable. but admitting that i desire it goes a long way towards figuring out how it will happen. even though it also makes me feel my lack of resources more acutely.
treyf[info]treyf on July 18th, 2007 02:47 pm (UTC)
Hi again, Dean- I sure hope you'll consider expanding your little economics CR group beyond your circle of friends to include some of us who are more or less on our own in our lives with this stuff. I've actually started some conversations based around these ideas (and others I see as related) with people in my life, and I've pretty much been shut down from the start. I feel like I'm nagging people in my life who don't want to have these conversations- and yet, I also feel like I'm not edgy and political enough to feel comfortable asking to be included in the conversations other people are having. Very high school deja vu kind of feeling.
cruciferous[info]cruciferous on July 18th, 2007 05:38 pm (UTC)
good point
tey, thanks for bringing this up. i hadn't thought about how the way i was writing about doing this work within social groups can include reproducing exclusivity. i think what i am trying to get at is how in many cases the best people to make change with are those you already know and have different kinds of trust or emotional intimacy with. so often, people go looking to do social justice work outside their own communities, and this can include really colonizing and paternalistic approaches when white people and/or people with class and educational privilege do it.

i was trying to think about a model that encourages people to do work in their 'home' spaces, recognizing that oppressive systems are produced and reproduced here, not just "out there." I was also thinking about how hard this conversation is and how difficult it might be to build it, or even get people to show up, to a big anonymous event about it, and how we might build it into existing networks instead. at the same time, i totally agree that it shouldn't only be that. when i was talking to tyrone we were thinking about trying these things out, various kinds of events, and putting tools on a website where other people could try too, and all of us reporting back about what happened and what worked and didn't work well, encouraging people to pull together events structured in ways that make sense for the people they know. when i was talking to emily about the friends she and i share, she emphasized how there is a lot of hiding wealth going on in those circles, and we thought that something like a dinner party would appeal to those people in a way that an open event about this topic wouldn't because they are afraid to openly identify about this stuff.

at the same time, i could see pulling together more open events in other social/ political circles i'm a part of. i would love to do something like that, eventually, with trans people and allies, where we were coming together based on shared analysis around gender and using that as a stepping stone to start a conversation about class and wealth redistribution. i would still want it to be small and local, like 20 ppl or less, because of the need to establish trust and non-judgment in the room. but i think if the people we were inviting were already political and open to going to a workshop like this it could be more of an open call, and the use of friend circle stuff to bring people together wouldn't be as essential.

thanks for bringing up this point. i really hate the ways that "coolness" and other social hierarchies, many of which continue to code class through things like clothing, endlessly haunt our lives far after high school. it sick. its good to think about how not to reproduce it in this work.
mable[info]indomitable666 on July 18th, 2007 05:28 pm (UTC)
dean, this is pooja. i'm not sure if you knew i had an lj, my entries are not usually as thoughtful or povoking as yours. but im so interested in economic redistribution and hypocricy , like how i refuse to buy an a/c even though i havent been sleeping more than like 3 hours a night bc its so hot - bc its so bad for the environment/expensive/unecessary/capitalist/im tough and from florida, but how i will totally buy myself a fancy cup of coffee bc i "need" it to do work for the movement (ha), although i would never buy starbucks coffee bc omg, they give money to settlements in the west bank in palestine, etc. anyways, id love to chat more with you about this stuff, maybe even tonight at drinks w/ dean . xo
cruciferous[info]cruciferous on July 18th, 2007 05:41 pm (UTC)
can't wait
pooja,
i can't wait to talk more about all of this with you. you know its just another realm in which i'm going to force you to write and publish articles. they won't have to be so long and heavily footnoted this time, though, i promise.
i can't wait to see how many thousands of layers you're wearing in the heat.
xo dean
[info]rubychard on July 18th, 2007 06:35 pm (UTC)

I would love to be a part of this CR group/dinner party/whatever it turns out to be.

I’ve been thinking about this stuff again after your series of posts, Dean, and once thing that’s sticking in my head is how we practically deal with this stuff in a big-picture or at least a community-based way. That is, there’s the question of what I or you or any other individual does with the money they earn or inherit – like, if I put money in a retirement account or if I hand that money to someone who is currently old and doesn’t have enough to live in (ie, individual redistribution.) But I want to think about ways that we can come together and create systems and plans and projects that will take care of us, and of others too, when we’re old, and how we can put our money into that. Otherwise it feels like choosing between me and someone else (ie, who gets my paycheck?), and I’d much rather look for a way to support an “us”… both because that’s the world I want to see, and because yes, I do worry about my long-term security. (And partially that worry is class training – being raised upper middle class- and then also partially a result of choices I’ve been making more recently, like taking a significant pay cut to work at a small new nonprofit.)
Gunner[info]gendercrash on July 18th, 2007 06:46 pm (UTC)
Inspired ramblings
I often get turned off by conversations around economics and class, because of the judgment that gets thrown around (I am just as guilty as the next person). So to lessen that judgment for myself, I have began to ask why someone shops, buys, etc... what is the personal connection? Individually, many people have that one (or more) item, place, corporations... etc.. that they won't buy, use, etc... but on the flip side there are others who have reasons for buying, using, etc.. some personal, some because of local experience. Is it that the local Starbucks in your town recruits and hires transgender people and homeless/marginally housed folks (that has happened here in Boston)... or is that for someone having a cell phone is a line to safety (often for survivors of violence), or sometimes cheaper than a landline or not buying something because of reducing their own enviromental impact... choosing to be personally low tech, but accessing and contributing to technology in shared spaces etc...

There are so many possibilities, so many stories to learn from...

I have been and want to continue to be thoughtful about my consumption, so I want to listen about why or why not someone does or does not buy. I want to be informed, but not be judged by the decsions I have choosen for myself. That is the fine line I think sometimes gets crossed in larger activist conversations about consumption, material good, or economics.

For myself, having grown up poor, not having much access, and having lived through being homeless... much of those circumstances include heaps of judgment, guilt, and being told what you can and cannot do more often, (because for some reason if you have nothing you get bossed around more).

Part of the larger class conversation has to include reducing that judgment, guilt, and being told what to do as well as helping people heal from it, particularly poor people and those who grew up poor.


(Anonymous) on July 23rd, 2007 08:18 pm (UTC)
compost guilt
I DO feel incredibly guilty about throwing away my compostable scraps. I've lived in back-to-basics communities and I know what a waste it is. And commercial fertilizer is used all around me, in my condo, at the community garden, by my neighbors etc. I think the truth is that none of us (myself included) feel free to really live the way we know we can live, and convince ourselves that, for whatever fucked up reason, we want to live the way we think we have to live. The exaggerated defensiveness is a result of us sliding down one giant slippery slope of apparent helplessness. If it is a lie that I can't really help the environment just a little bit by driving less, and it is a lie that I can't contribute a little to easing the civil war in the congo by weaning myself from hi-tech, and it is a lie that I am one check away from the poor house, and it is a lie that retirement money grows without ill consequences, and it is a lie that rich people, and poor people and powerful people all deserve what they have or don't have, then all of my life is one big fat lie. So what can I do amidst this mass delusion? I could be mad at the person who says I can make changes in my life and those around me (because, hello! are they living in the same shitty world as I am?) or I could find ways to feel a little less helpless.